Talk: Runner-up

Runner-up have been twenty-five

Dia Frampton, Juliet Simms, Terry McDermott, Michelle Chamuel, Jacquie Lee, Jake Worthington, Matt McAndrew, Meghan Linsey, Emily Ann Roberts, Adam Wakefield, Billy Gilman, Lauren Duski, Addison Agen, Britton Buchanan, Chris Kroeze, Gyth Rigdon, Ricky Duran, Toneisha Harris, Jim Ranger, Kenzie Wheeler, Wendy Moten, bodie, Grace West, Ruby Leigh, and Josh Sanders.